
15 / 17 · Criminal Code, ss. 673 – 696, 812 – 839
Criminal Appeals
A conviction or sentence is not always the end. We review the trial record for legal errors, file on time, seek your release while the appeal is decided, and argue it before the appeal court.
- Conviction appeals
- Sentence appeals
- Bail pending appeal
- Summary conviction appeals
- Responding to Crown appeals
- Extensions of time to appeal
What is at stake
Why this charge needs a real defence.
An appeal is not a new trial. The appeal court reviews the record of what happened, and the deadlines are short: in Ontario, a notice of appeal must generally be filed within 30 days of sentencing. Missing it means asking the court for permission to appeal late. A successful appeal can mean an acquittal, a new trial, or a lower sentence.
How it is done
How we build your defence.
- 1
Protect the deadline
We confirm the deadline, file the notice of appeal, and order the transcripts. If the time has already passed, we assess an application to extend it.
- 2
Find the errors that matter
We read the whole record: the evidence, the rulings, and the judge's reasons or the jury charge. Appeals succeed on legal errors, unreasonable verdicts and miscarriages of justice, not on disagreement with the result.
- 3
Seek release while the appeal is heard
If you are in custody, we apply for bail pending appeal, showing that the appeal has merit, that you will surrender when required, and that detention is not needed in the public interest.
- 4
Write and argue the appeal
The written argument, the factum, carries most appeals. We build it around the strongest grounds and argue it before the Superior Court or the Court of Appeal for Ontario.
What we look for
The issues that decide these cases.
- 01
Errors of law
Misdirections to a jury, the wrong legal test, or evidence wrongly admitted or excluded.
- 02
Unreasonable verdict
A verdict that no properly instructed judge or jury could reasonably have reached on the evidence.
- 03
Unfit sentence
A sentence that is demonstrably unfit, or that rests on an error in principle, can be reduced.
- 04
Fresh evidence
Evidence that could not reasonably have been found for trial and could have changed the result.
Possible outcomes
What a good result can look like.
- An acquittal entered on appeal
- A new trial ordered
- A sentence reduced or varied
- Release on bail while the appeal is decided
Every case turns on its own facts. These are examples of results that may be available, not a prediction or guarantee of the outcome in your matter.
Questions
What people ask us first.
In Ontario, a notice of appeal must generally be filed within 30 days of sentencing, for appeals against conviction and against sentence. If the deadline has passed, the appeal court can extend it, but you must explain the delay and show the appeal has merit. Call as soon as possible.
In many cases, yes. The court considers whether the appeal is not frivolous, whether you will surrender into custody when required, and whether detention is necessary in the public interest. For an appeal against sentence only, it also considers whether detention would cause unnecessary hardship.
Appeals from indictable offences go to the Court of Appeal for Ontario. Appeals in summary conviction matters go first to the Superior Court of Justice, with a further appeal to the Court of Appeal only with permission.
Yes, but in indictable cases only on a question of law alone. The Crown can also appeal a sentence it considers too low. We respond to Crown appeals and defend the result you won at trial.
Guides
Read more before you decide.
Next step
Talk to us about your criminal appeals matter.
A short conversation now can prevent mistakes that are hard to undo later. What you tell us is confidential.
