
14 / 17 · Charter of Rights and Freedoms, ss. 7 – 11, 24
Charter Challenges
When police or the state break the rules, the Charter gives you remedies, from excluding evidence to stopping the prosecution. We look for every breach in the disclosure and prove it in court.
- Search warrant challenges
- Warrantless searches of homes, cars and phones
- Racial profiling and pretext stops
- Right to counsel breaches
- Unreasonable delay (section 11(b))
- Exclusion of evidence
What is at stake
Why this charge needs a real defence.
Evidence obtained by breaching your Charter rights can be excluded, and without it the Crown often has no case. Delay past the Supreme Court of Canada's ceilings, 18 months in the Ontario Court of Justice and 30 months in the Superior Court, is presumed unreasonable. None of these remedies is automatic: the breach has to be found in the disclosure, proven with evidence, and argued.
How it is done
How we build your defence.
- 1
Get the full disclosure
We obtain the officers' notes, body-worn and in-car camera video, dispatch and radio records, and the sworn information behind any warrant, and press for anything missing.
- 2
Test the grounds
Every stop, detention and search needs legal authority. We compare what police said in their notes and warrant applications with what the video and records actually show.
- 3
Cross-examine the officers
Charter applications are decided on evidence. Careful cross-examination is often what shows the grounds were missing, a warrant was misleading, or a traffic stop was a pretext.
- 4
Argue the remedy
We ask the court to exclude the evidence under section 24(2), or for a stay of proceedings or another remedy where the breach or the delay is serious enough.
What we look for
The issues that decide these cases.
- 01
Unreasonable search (s. 8)
A search without a warrant is presumed unreasonable. Warrants built on thin, stale or misleading grounds can be set aside.
- 02
Arbitrary detention (s. 9)
A stop based on a hunch, or influenced in any degree by race, is not lawful. A traffic stop used as a pretext to investigate something else can be arbitrary.
- 03
Right to counsel (s. 10(b))
Police must tell you of your right to a lawyer without delay, let you use it in private, and hold off questioning until you have.
- 04
Unreasonable delay (s. 11(b))
Delay past the ceiling that was not caused by the defence is presumed unreasonable, and the court must remedy it.
Possible outcomes
What a good result can look like.
- Evidence excluded and charges withdrawn or dismissed
- A stay of proceedings
- Statements to police ruled inadmissible
- A stronger position to negotiate a resolution
Every case turns on its own facts. These are examples of results that may be available, not a prediction or guarantee of the outcome in your matter.
Questions
What people ask us first.
Only in limited situations: for example, a search incident to a lawful arrest, a search you freely agree to, or where a specific law gives police the power. A routine traffic stop does not by itself let police search your car. If they searched without lawful authority, the evidence may be excluded.
Racial profiling happens when race or a racial stereotype is used, consciously or not and to any degree, in deciding to stop, detain, search or question someone. Ontario's Court of Appeal has held that this makes the detention arbitrary even if the officer had other reasons too.
Under R. v. Jordan, delay beyond 18 months in the Ontario Court of Justice, or 30 months in the Superior Court, is presumed unreasonable once delay caused by the defence is deducted. Amendments passed in 2026 direct courts to consider other remedies before staying the charges, so the application needs to be prepared carefully and brought on time.
Not automatically. Before excluding evidence, the court weighs how serious the breach was, its impact on your rights, and society's interest in a trial on the merits. Clear evidence of a serious breach is what wins these applications.
Guides
Read more before you decide.
- Can police search my car without a warrant in Ontario?A traffic stop is not a licence to search. Here is when police in Ontario can search a vehicle without a warrant, what you must and need not do at the roadside, and what happens if a search was unlawful.
- When a criminal case takes too long: unreasonable delay and the Jordan ceilingsSection 11(b) of the Charter guarantees the right to be tried within a reasonable time. Here is how the 18- and 30-month ceilings from R. v. Jordan work, what counts as defence delay, and how the 2026 amendments changed the remedy.
Next step
Talk to us about your charter challenges matter.
A short conversation now can prevent mistakes that are hard to undo later. What you tell us is confidential.
