Bail · 3 min read
What is a bail review in Ontario?
If a justice of the peace refused bail, or set conditions that cannot work, a judge of the Superior Court of Justice can review the decision. Here is how a bail review works, what the judge looks at, and how to prepare one.
By Sahra Baregzay, criminal defence lawyer · Updated
The short answer
- A bail review asks a Superior Court judge to change a detention order, or bail conditions, made in the Ontario Court of Justice.
- It is not a fresh hearing: the judge needs a legal error, a clearly inappropriate decision, or new evidence showing a material change.
- The transcript of the first hearing is needed, so order it right away.
- A stronger plan, such as a new surety or a confirmed treatment bed, is often what wins a review.
Who can ask for a bail review
Most bail hearings in Ontario are held before a justice of the peace in the Ontario Court of Justice. If the accused is ordered detained, they can apply to a judge of the Superior Court of Justice to review the detention order under section 520 of the Criminal Code. The Crown can also ask for a review if it believes a release order was wrong, under section 521.
A review can also target conditions. If someone was released, but on terms that make it impossible to work, care for children, or live anywhere, a review or a variation may fix them.
For murder and the other offences listed in section 469 of the Criminal Code, bail is decided by a Superior Court judge from the start, and a review goes to the Court of Appeal for Ontario.
What the judge looks at
The Supreme Court of Canada explained in R. v. St-Cloud (2015) that a bail review is not a second chance to argue the same hearing. The reviewing judge can step in only in three situations:
- the first decision contained an error of law;
- the decision was clearly inappropriate, given all the evidence; or
- there is new evidence showing a material and relevant change in circumstances.
The third ground is the most common in practice. A new or stronger surety, a confirmed place to live, a treatment program that has accepted the accused, or electronic monitoring can all be new evidence.
How a bail review works, step by step
- Order the transcript of the original bail hearing, and gather the exhibits and the reasons the justice gave.
- Strengthen the plan: identify sureties, and confirm housing, work or school, and any treatment or supervision.
- Serve the application on the Crown. The Criminal Code requires at least two clear days' written notice, and a well-prepared review usually takes longer than that to assemble.
- Sureties swear affidavits and may be cross-examined at the review.
- The judge hears argument, usually in a single sitting, and decides whether to cancel the detention order and release the accused on conditions.
How long it takes
A review can take several weeks to reach a courtroom, mostly because of the time needed to obtain transcripts and a hearing date. Starting the same day bail is denied makes a real difference.
Separately, the Criminal Code requires a detention review when someone has been held for an extended period without trial, even if no one applies for one.
Reverse onus cases after the 2026 reforms
Since the federal bail reforms took effect in July 2026, more charges place the burden on the accused to show why they should be released, including home break-ins, violent or organized auto theft, human trafficking and violent extortion. In those cases the ladder principle, which favours the least restrictive form of release, no longer applies, and the release plan must clearly show how it addresses the risks.
That makes careful preparation for a review even more important: the plan put forward needs to answer the concerns the first justice gave for detention, one by one.
Common questions
Yes, but not right away. Once a review has been decided, another cannot be brought for 30 days without a judge's permission, and any further application needs a real change in circumstances since the last decision.
Usually yes, often by video from the detention centre. The proposed sureties normally attend and may be asked questions.
No. A variation changes the conditions of an existing release, often with the Crown's consent. A review challenges a decision, usually a detention order, before a higher court.
This guide is general information about criminal law in Ontario, current to November 12, 2026. It is not legal advice, and every case turns on its own facts. Reading it does not create a lawyer-client relationship.